Fall 2025: The Window Smart Investors Are Quietly Capitalizing On

There’s a subtle shift happening right now in the real estate world—and most investors aren’t fully paying attention to it.

Inventory is creeping up.
Competition is easing.
Sellers are becoming more flexible.
And buyers? A decent chunk of them are sidelined, discouraged, or waiting for a magical drop in interest rates.

This combination doesn’t happen often. It’s like the housing market equivalent of a solar eclipse: brief, predictable if you know where to look, and full of opportunity for those prepared.

So… how do you take advantage of it?

Simple: go off-market.

While everyone else waits for the perfect deal to appear on Zillow, the MLS, or whatever aggregator hits their inbox, you can go straight to the source—the property owner.

And the most effective way to build that connection right now?

Handwritten mail.

Not printed junk.
Not generic postcards.
Real ink. Real handwriting. Real connection.

That’s where First Touch Letters comes in.

Why Off-Market Works Especially Well Right Now

Fall 2025 gives you something rare: motivated owners who aren’t necessarily ready (or excited) to jump into a noisy listing process. Maybe they’ve been thinking about selling. Maybe they’re tired of property management. Maybe their land’s just sitting there producing… nothing.

When you send a handwritten First Touch letter:

  • You stand out instantly.

  • You introduce yourself as the solution.

  • You start a relationship that doesn’t feel salesy.

It’s personal. Authentic. Human.

…and no, AI-generated mass mail doesn’t create that same response.

Even BiggerPockets Is Noticing the Shift

Earlier this month, BiggerPockets published a piece called “Fall 2025 Is a Sweet Spot for Investors” — and they highlighted exactly what we’re seeing:

More listings.
Less buyer competition.
Better leverage for investors.
But only for a limited time.

This window won’t stay open forever. When affordability improves or rate sentiment shifts, competition rushes back in like a tidal wave.

The investors who build off-market pipelines now are quietly stacking deals before everyone wakes up to the opportunity.

Your Secret Weapon: Consistency + Sequence

One letter is cute.
One postcard is fun.
But consistent mail?

That’s where deals live.

We typically recommend 4–6 months of steady outreach. Not aggressive. Just present.

And yes—our Cosmic Postcard Sequence was designed for this exact environment:

✨ Mildly humorous
🪐 Visually memorable
📬 Impossible to ignore in a boring mail stack

Pair it with handwritten letters to warm the relationship and then drip playful, eye-catching follow-ups that remind the owner, “Hey… I’m still here if you’re thinking about selling.”

Because Here’s the Real Truth…

You can:
✔️ Pull niche lists
✔️ Analyze markets perfectly
✔️ Educate yourself all day

But if you’re not talking to actual property owners,
you don’t have deal flow.

Off-market mail solves that.

And right now?
It’s cheaper, easier, and more effective than waiting for the MLS to magically hand you a perfect property.

How to Get Started (Without Overthinking It)

1️⃣ Build a targeted list
2️⃣ Send a First Touch Letter, fully handwritten
3️⃣ Follow up with the Cosmic Postcard Sequence
4️⃣ Track calls, conversions, and timing
5️⃣ Repeat monthly

We do all of the mail prep for you—printing, writing, sequencing, stamping, everything.

You just answer the phone when the calls come in.

The Sweet Spot Won’t Last Forever

BiggerPockets is calling it out.
Data backs it up.
We’re seeing response rates rise.

Fall 2025 is an opportunity window.

The investors who move off-market now will be the ones picking up deals quietly while everyone else hesitates, scrolls, waits, and over-analyzes.

Final Thought

In this business, timing rewards those who take action—not those who refresh listing sites hoping for something magical to appear.

A consistent off-market mailing strategy, supported by handwritten first-touch letters and a memorable postcard sequence, positions you in front of motivated sellers before real competition ever shows up.

And when the market tightens again (because it always does), the investors who built relationships early will already be holding the deals everyone else wishes they found.

So stack the odds in your favor:

  • Go personal.

  • Go consistent.

  • Go off-market.

  • And above all… keep showing up.

Because deal flow doesn’t belong to the loudest investors.
It belongs to the ones who mail with purpose—over time.

Back to blog